Sunday, September 5, 2010

Can We Modify the Definition of Kashrut?

We are what we eat.  The more I study Jewish dietary laws and the reasoning behind them, I find that dietary choices reflect one's personality.  The piggishness of many Americans brings new meaning to "you eat like a pig."  In contrast, people who make conscientious decisions regarding their diet, whether it is in keeping with the traditional notion of kashrut or keeping vegetarian out of a sanctity of [animal] life, are, by and large, more refined individuals.

Back in December 2009, I had done a series of blogs on what it means to keep kosher.  I had analyzed the reasoning from spiritual, ethical, nationalistic, and health-based reasons given from Jewish tradition.  Even after posting those blogs, I had always came back to the questions of "Why Kosher?" and "What Does It Mean to Keep Kosher?"  I ask these questions for two reasons.  The first reason is that I am a strong proponent in the Maimonidean concept that the Torah is human-oriented, which means that the purposes of Torah are to refine the individual and to refine humanity.  The second reason is because so much has changed in recent history that different questions are being asked than they were fifty or a hundred years ago.

Some people might be shocked to find that the motivation for writing this blog entry is an article from the Reform Movement that touches upon this very topic.  Although I generally disagree with the Reform Movement for a myriad of reasons, I still believe that a broken clock can at least be right twice a day.  And so it goes with this article.  It got me pondering whether we can modify the definition of kashrut.  For the more traditionally-minded, I'm not going to tackle the myth of "nothing ever changes in Judaism" because it should be self-evident that plenty has changed since Moses came down from Mount Sinai.  But I hope that you also realize that I chose the word "modify" over "change," which has the implication that I am not looking to automatically throw out every dietary law on the books.  I am, however, looking for a way to make sure that by either rendering new meanings or re-discovering traditional meanings to our dietary practices, kashrut becomes neither trivial nor vapid.

I am glad to see that the Reform Movement brought up questions of whether it has a hechsher or if is in accordance with Jewish law.  These are important questions to bring up in mind since it we are talking about what it means to eat Jewishly.  Ultimately, when I refer to modification, I am talking about the possibility of taking other factors into consideration when determining whether something is fit to eat.  I think asking this is of importance because the word "kosher" literally means "fit" or "proper," and is not limited to food consumption.  Therefore, it gives us license to bring in other factors. 

For instance, the article brings up whether in our food consumption, we violate the mitzvah of b'al tashchit (not wantonly wasting or destroying).  If Jewish tradition teaches us that we are supposed to be so meticulous that we are not supposed to even destroy a mustard seed, then we should bring this environmental consciousness within our Jewish practice.  By considering b'al taschit, we can turn something as seemingly mundane as recycling or not buying more food than we need into a spiritual act.

Shemirat Haguf, protection of the body, is another Jewish value I think many forget.  Is the consistent eating of fatty meats and sugar-packed desserts kosher, even though they have kosher certification on it?  Nope!  Deuteronomy 4:9, 15 teaches us to protect our bodies because our bodies are the vessels in which we do mitzvot.  We are also taught to choose life, and that means prolonging our lives.  It doesn't matter if the unhealthy food stocked in your kitchen has the proper certification.  If you are making poor dietary decisions that deteriorate the overall health of your body, that is not kosher.

Tza'ar baylei chayim, the mandate not to treat animals cruelly, is yet another Jewish value to consider.  We have to keep in mind that modern agriculture is very different from that of our ancestors.  It has essentially become a greed-motivated, assembly line process where animals are cramped into cages (i.e., it's anything but free range) and treated miserably.  Do we go about considering the treatment of our animals when we purchase them?  Shechita, kosher slaughter, is the most compassionate way to kill an animal.  But if we are going to be concerned with the suffering of an animal at Point Z, shouldn't we be equally concerned with the animal's well-being from points A to Y?

Postscript: Much of the questions that the Reform Movement presented in their article are still in the exploratory phase for me and my attempt to properly define what it means to eat in a kosher manner.  Even so, I can state that in my life, keeping kosher will go beyond the certification process.  As I continue to ponder these questions, I hope to come up with more answers and more insight not only as to what keeping kosher means, but also why and how these new factors resonate with a twenty-first century Jew who is looking to preserve tradition while still bringing in innovation and change in his Jewish practice.   

The Unemployment Rate, a Sign of Dismay

Another month of disappointing employment statistics comes in as this country dealt with yet another month of net job loss: 54,000 to be exact.  President Obama, a.k.a. Sir Hope 'n Change, has once again shown us that change is not necessarily a good thing, and to rely on something like hope doesn't change the fact that unemployment went back up to 9.6%.  What makes the numbers more disturbing is, as AEI scholar Henry Olsen points out, is the percentage of Americans who have jobs, which, of date, has almost approached that of the early 1980s:



Olson rightfully states his worries:

The import of the employment rate is clearer when one compares it and the unemployment rate to data from last August. America's adult population has risen by 2 million people since then, but the number of adults with jobs has dropped by 180,000. The unemployment rate declined slightly despite these numbers, from 9.7 percent to 9.6 percent, because over 2.3 million people have left the labor force entirely, so discouraged they are no longer even looking for work. The employment rate more accurately reflects that despair, sliding down from 59.1 percent to 58.5 percent.

What is bothersome is that these worries go beyond the short-term.  As the Brooking Institute illustrates, this is going to affect the long-term, as well, particularly for young adults.  Statistically speaking, young adults (i.e., age 18-24) are have been hit approximately twice as hard as everybody else.  Even setting aside young adults for a moment and looking at the bigger picture, it is going to take anywhere from five to twelve years for this country to return to pre-recession levels, and this presumes that we will have a consistently sizeable job growth.





I understand why many are starting to label this economic upheavel "the Great Recession."  Unless an economic miracle comes along, we are looking at a long road to recovery.  It's hard not to be a pessimist during these times, especially with an incompetent present.  But I am going to make a prediction here.  Unless Obama does something to prevent the tax hikes that are scheduled to take place on January 1, 2011, he is only prolonging the recession.  If he does not step in and make the taxation system less burdensome for [small] businesses, I can guarantee that he will be a one-term president.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

The Double-Edged Sword of Facebook

Technology has brought on many advances in the past fifty years alone.  We are able to live longer, healthier lives.  The Internet has given mankind unprecedented access to information.  Mass communications have given us the ability to communicate with somebody halfway across the world within mere seconds.  Being able to travel to foreign countries has never been easier.  I am truly amazed at man's technological progress in recent years. 

As astonishing as it all can be, I think that technology has come with unanticipated backlash that has stunted the individual and his potential to grow.  Let's take social networking programs such as Facebook an example.  Facebook has helped me connect with people that are hundreds of miles away, even though I wished they were right here.  In that respect, these programs are great.  I also use Facebook to connect with friends that I haven't heard from since grade school.  That sounds touching and nostalgic, until you realize that if they were really your friends, you would have never lost touch with them in the first place.  Even if they moved away, you would have still made the effort to be in communication.

What I am trying to drive at is that for many individuals, Facebook has become a replacement of social interaction rather than an enhancer of interacting with other individuals.  People find Facebook to be nice because they don't have to interact with others.  It's another result of the extreme individualism we see, which leads to extreme isolationism since the individual is self-involved. 

The issue goes beyond being self-absorbed.  It shortens one's attention span.  We communicate ourselves in Facebook wall postings that are so short that the notion of a fifteen-second sound byte seems to drag on forever.  Even talking in abbreviations such as OMG and LOL has seeped over into daily conversation.  Lack of attention span results in a lack of discipline.  Lack of discipline leads to lack of self growth.  Lack of self growth leads to pedantically and pathetically shallow people.  Sound character and a good head on one's shoulder becomes a rarity, and common sense isn't so common anymore.

Is this diatribe going to cause me to cancel my Facebook account?  Surprisingly not.  I cannot stand the fact that a majority of Facebook subscribers use Facebook as a crutch for their inadequacies to deal with actual social interaction and developing real-life relations with people around them.  My disgust, however, does not negate my usage of the service, as I view it as a utile medium to connect with others without having it consume my entire being.  Use Facebook to plan social events with others.  Use it as a gradual means to have a more meaningful, face-to-face interaction.  But don't treat it as a substitute for the essential human need of live, social interaction because it will ultimately hollow out that which makes you a human being.      

The Koran: The Real Root of the Arab-Israeli Conflict

When discussing the “Arab-Israeli conflict,” many, including Obama, are sadly under the disillusion that the heart of the issue is territorial disputes.  The idea has some impressive gift wrapping not only because it sounds so simple, because it makes this alleged solution tangible.  “Oh, if we give the Palestinians ‘their land’ back, they’ll be content and the hostility towards Israel will dissipate.”  And so goes the mentality of the ignorant.  Unfortunately, reality unravels it cold, bitter self in a way that would make one cynical.  Israel has tried "land for peace" since its inception!  The fact that Israel has given away 93% of the disputed territories from the Six Day War does not seem to abate a thing.     

In response to the ineffectiveness of the "land for peace" theory, I must say the following. Whether or not it is politically correct to say this is immaterial and is of no concern to me, mostly because I view political correctness as another way for feeble-minded people to stifle any attempt at intellectual growth and prosperity. So here it goes: the root of Palestinian hatred, and thus the root of the Arab-Israeli conflict, is not territorial; it is religious.  In case that was not clear enough, let me rephrase: tension in the Middle East is caused by Jew hatred stemming from the Koran. As Hagai Mazus, a PhD that teaches Islamic Studies at Hudson University, points out in his article The Root of the Arab-Israeli Conflict: The Classic Islamic View of the Jews, this fight goes all the way back to the days of Mohammed.  As soon as the Jews of Medina rejected Mohammed in the seventh century, Judeo-Islamic relations have never been the same, which is something Mazus outlines in his second part to his recently-written article where he analyzes Koranic teaches and subsequent application thereof. 

This is why the dhimmi status was created, which is a second-class, subservient status given to non-Muslim monotheists that I wrote about a few months back.  The status of a dhimmi was never set in stone because it was always contingent upon the success of the ruling caliphate at the time.  If all was well, Jews [and Christians] could hold high-ranking positions, although the “stain” of being a dhimmi still existed.  If the political scene went sour, you had best look out!  In spite of apologists saying that conditions for a Jew were better under Muslim rule than during Christian rule, a fact which, for the most part, I wouldn’t dispute, we seem to forget that this medieval view of the non-believer has consistently been applied throughout Muslim history.  

People do not realize, or rather, choose not to realize because of some form of cognitive dissonance, that Islam is inherently fundamentalist, and that anybody who steps out of that mold is a radical within the Islamic world.  It is not solely the fundamentalism or the literalism that bothers me here.  It is the fact that the Koran shows high levels of acrimony towards non-believers.  The enmity is amplified by the Muslims constantly viewing the Jew and any other non-believer with disgust, and not just any disgust, but so much disgust that they even codified the second-class status into its legal corpus.  It is sad as it is true, but anti-Semitism is built into the Muslim psyche.  If a Muslim decided to abandon anti-Semitism, they would, in effect, be abandoning mainstream Islam.  The Muslim who wanted to live peacefully with Jews and other non-believers would either have to abandon Islam as a whole or join Sufism or the Ba'hai faith, neither of which are technically considered to be Islam, even though they have some basis in Islam.       

Whether you think that Islamic reformation is possible, that we need to eradicate the [Islamic] enemy, or some solution in between, it all seems irrelevant to discuss at this time.  In order to adequately and accurately discuss Middle Eastern politics, we have to first realize the very root of the Arab-Israel conflict is Koranic in nature.  Only then can we create measures in which to mitigate the problem.

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Resolving Rationalism with the Superstition Behind Tashlich

During the first day of Rosh Hashana, there is a well-established practice known as תשליך.  The word itself comes from Micah 7:19, where "you will cast all their sins into the depths of the sea."  What the practice entails is finding a body of running water and throwing pieces of bread into that body of water as a symbolic casting of one's sins.

What many do not realize is that this ceremony has its origins in superstitions.  Rabbi Israel Drazin, in his intellectually stimulating book entitled "Maimonides: The Exceptional Mind," outlines the history of this ritual in depth.  Essentially, we are dealing with a practice that emanated from ancient notions, one of them being that G-d and demons can be found near water.  If you believe in G-d's omnipresence, this notion should make you stop and think for a moment.  But many biblical figures thought so, whether it was Abraham who made a covenant before a well in Be'er Sheva (Genesis 21:31-32), King David's son, Adonijah, who thinks he can offer a sacrifice in front of a river and help him succeed his father as king (1 Kings 1:9), or the Psalmist (29:3, 139).  Even the Talmud tells of stories such as feeding spirits to appease them (Chullin 105b) and drinking water from a river at night is bad because of the shabiri, the demons that cause blindness (Pesachim 112a). 

By the time this practice was created in the Middle Ages, it makes sense why the primary theme of this practice was to bribe Satan.  The Kabbalists added the practice of shaking of the ends of one's clothing to shake off the klippah, as if the act itself absolved them of any sins.  This was problematic because taking the non-rationalist approach meant believing that the ceremony literally absolved one from their sins.  Since superstitions such as these make people small-minded, this mentality had the potential from steering people from doing actual repentance, which is why so many rabbis opposed the practice.

This brings me to the important question of "do superstitious origins negate the ceremony's validity?"  If your intention is to bribe Satan with pieces of bread, as if bits of stale bread is going to distract G-d's servant from doing his job, then I would have to say that this practice is absolutely ridiculous.  Even saying מנהג אבותינ תורה הוא ("the customs of our ancestors is law [for us]") would be insufficient because customs can be overturned in Jewish law.

In spite of these non-rational origins, there can be reconciliation between the practice's history and how we perceive the practice today.  Even though I believe that "tradition for tradition's sake" is as dangerous and menacing of an argument as "change for change's sake," I nevertheless enjoy Judaism for its traditions.  Judaism is uniquely beautiful for the continuity it has kept over the centuries, hence its allure for me.  I can perform the same practice as my Jewish ancestors did back in the Middle Ages, but I can derive a different purpose and meaning from it.

To paraphrase R. Aryeh Kaplan in his book Jewish Meditation, a mitzvah can be an action-based meditation.  This insight has changed how I view mitzvot.  The mitzvah is supposed to get your mind engaged and focused on G-dliness.  Let's apply that concept to תשליך.  When you are casting the bread into the water, what should be on your mind?  That these crumbs are a metaphorical representation of my sins, and that by throwing them away, you are starting anew.  There's that Jewish theme of renewal again.   How about the water?  In Judaism, water symbolizes life and renewal.  Much like Daniel (10:4) did, we can experience G-d's revelation in front of water and contemplate the vast wonders that life has to offer.  Let's try an insight with the fish, since one is supposed to find a body of water with fish.  As Rabbi Isaiah Horowitz points out, just as fish have no eyelids and always have their eyes open, we should always "keep our eyes open" by constantly being attentive to G-d and His will.  Even the act of being in front of a body of water can be an opportunity to realize G-d's wonder through His creations. 

As you go to symbolically cast your sins in the ceremony of תשליך this year, take just one of those insights and keep it in the back of your mind throughout the experience.  I guarantee it will enhance your appreciation for תשליך.

Sunday, August 22, 2010

The BBC is Pro-Israel for Once?!

This one took me by surprise.  Not only are we talking about a European media outlet, but we are talking about one in Britain that has been accused on more than one occassion of leaning Left, which translates into major anti-Israel sentiment.  The anti-Zionist/anti-Semitic (anti-Zionist, anti-Semitic, same difference!) groups are on the warpath in Europe as they actually found the BBC's coverage on the flotilla scenario to be pro-Israel.  I guess there's a first time for everything.  I hope this is a new trend in European media reporting, but I think it might be more realistic to just take this small victory and go from there.  In any event, per a link from Aish HaTorah, here is the actual BBC coverage:




Friday, August 20, 2010

Parsha Ki Tetze: Can We Avert Out Fate?

Karl Marx believed that history was nothing more than a cyclical clash of the bourgeoisie against the proletariat. Greek mythology advanced the idea that you cannot avoid your fate, an idea best illustrated by the story of Oedipus. The Twinkie Defense exemplifies the notion of genetic determinism. Calvinist predestination states that G-d “freely and unchangeably ordained whatsoever comes to pass,” even when it comes to G-d predetermining whether you receive salvation or eternal damnation.


What these four very different paradigms are echoing is what many have thought throughout history: our circumstances are beyond our control, and there is nothing we can do to choose, let alone change, our outcome. We call this point of view pre-determinism.

Are we really stuck with the cards we have been dealt, and we’re just going along for the ride? Or do we have enough control of the outcome that we are able to dodge “fate” and actually prolong our lives?

When it comes to making a choice between right and wrong, Judaism unequivocally advocates free will. Otherwise, G-d giving us a bunch of laws that we cannot follow would be a superfluous, farcical act. However, we have to realize that ethics (i.e., right vs. wrong) are merely reactionary choices to a given situation. How we respond to situations beyond our control (i.e., exerting self-control) is important because it doesn’t let external forces get the better of you. It has a degree of self-empowerment, and I’m not here to diminish that.

Instead of analyzing reactive self-empowerment, I would like to analyze the possibility of the proactive measure of prolonging one’s life. Going back to Calvinist predestination, we have no say in the matter. It’s all up to G-d, and we have to accept that everything is all G-d’s doing. This mentality leaves no leeway for free will in this area.

This week’s Parsha, on the other hand, has a different story to tell:

כִּי תִבְנֶה בַּיִת חָדָשׁ, וְעָשִׂיתָ מַעֲקֶה לְגַגֶּךָ; וְלא-תָשִׂים דָּמִים בְּבֵיתֶךָ, כִּי-יִפּל הַנּפֵל מִמֶּנּוּ.

When you build a new house, then you shall make a parapet for your roof, that you do not bring blood upon your house, if any man fall from it. -Deuteronomy 22:8 

In this instance, the Torah is commanding us to build a fence around our roof [if we have one]. Why? In order to protect those who are on the roof from falling off. The verse teaches us the importance of taking preventative measures to avoid dangerous situations (Talmud, Ketubot, 41b; Shulchan Aruch, Choshen Mishpta 427:7). If we take the Calvinist’s viewpoint that one’s longevity is predetermined and no human action could deter his inevitable surmise (i.e., it’s all in G-d’s hands), building such a fence would be a pointless endeavor. If the person’s date of death has not arrived, then the person would not need to be protected for the fence. We can use the same line of reasoning with the cities of refuge (Numbers 35:11-12) and exempting a soldier who just betrothed a wife from going into battles [lest he die in warfare and another man takes her to be his wife] (Deuteronomy 20:7).

G-d did not want us to only have the choice of whether to act ethically. He also gave us the choice between life and death, and commanded us to choose life so we may live (Deuteronomy 30). G-d is not some micro-managing interferer that treats us like infantile munchkins. G-d is much more like a parent who wants to see His children grow and learn how to stand on their own two feet. That is why He gives us the ability to prolong our lives. By realizing the power that G-d has given us as human beings, we can better appreciate the gift of life that He has given us.

שבת שלום!